Sunday, October 02, 2005

The Bihari

At the onset, let me give a brief background about where my roots are and why I say what I am going to say.

Baba was born and brought up in a pretty affluent family by Bihar standards, in a place called Siwan, which is by far the most gruesome example of a plagued Bihar town nowadays. Anyways, he completed his engineering, had a very bad patch during the JP movement when in between college he was left without classes/aim/motivation for a complete year, and then by dint and effort, landed up a job in Maharashtra State Electricity Board. He since then migrated out to Maharashtra and I was born and brought up there. As I always put it, I have been fortunate enough to have had the best of both the worlds: the Bihari mindset of working hard and respect and the Maharashtrian way of living fast and ensuring that the dearth of facilities like electricity and water don't come in the way of your progress.

Coming back to the point. I am a proud Bihari. Proud of my roots. Proud enough to engage in a furios debate with anyone who thinks otherwise of Bihar. Since my childhood I have been mocked at by fellow kids who always equated Bihar with 'a land of fat, stupid, dumb idiots.' I don't think I am as angry on them as I used to be when I was a kid because none of us mature enough then. But nowadays, it pains sometimes when grown-ups have the same kind of attitude. For someone who is reading these lines, it might occur that I am a big champion of Bihari sentimentalities and am overlooking the problems that has led Bihar to the state it is in today. Read on.

When I was a kid, I used to see that we rarely locked our homes in Maharashtra with 4-5 locks, as my Nani and Dadi used to do in Patna and Siwan. In Maharashtra, my sister and I were allowed to play in the open till late in the evening and were free to roam about. In Siwan however, Maa closely guarded us both. My chacha used to call me 'Disco Bhateeja' because I was a 'Bambaiya' (I have never lived in Mumbai, but to every person in Bihar, a Maharashtrian means a 'Bambaiya'). I was warned not to move around in T- Shirts and jeans for the fear of getting kidnapped. I was utterly confused. The open fields of Siwan, the wells, the river that went through the city, the ghats where we used to go for 'Chatth Pooja': these were better places to have fun and play ass kids than the concrete jungles of the cities of Maharashtra. I have seen kids aged 10-12 dying of meningitis because they couldn't get medicines on time. The last time I went to Siwan, it took me 8 hours for a 120 kms journey. That was 3 years ago. Things, I have heard, haven't changed.

I love the Bihari accent that has come to face severe contempt and scorn. It is a symbol of the Bihari stupidity. Why? Because it sounds funny. Why does it sound funny? Because most of the Hindi movies always had a village bumpkin who acted stupid irrespective of where in India he cam from, (it could have been Gujarat or Rajasthan), he always spoke in (distorted) Bhojpuri. (To all those misinformed people, there is no such dialect or language such as 'Bihari'. What it is confused with most often is 'Bhojpuri'). Why did it so happen that almost always the court jester was a Bihari? Because: look around you. Look at the number of Biharis around you. Because its the mass present everywhere. Be it a mason working to build your house (when we built our own house in Nasik, the mason, the carpenter and everyone involved were Biharis. Why? Because there weren't any other available), or your District Magistrate or the person who's blog you are reading now. Well, I will not be foolish to claim that 'we' are the single largest community and so on. But please recognise the penetration, right from rock bottom to the top.

But haven't we Indians mocked every community amongst ourselves? Sardars, gults, bangalis, tams, kannadigas, marathis.. the list is endless. I personally have had a taste of all this being in IIT Kharagpur, truly a diverse place. The point remains that whether it hurts a Sardar as much as it does a Bihari when you tease them?

Coming back to the language and the customs. How much I hate the fact that I don't have that kind of accent that Baba or chachaji has. Baba always says that Bhojpuri is dead. His generation was the last to speak proper Bhojpuri now. It has now become corrupt. What hasn't become corrupt in Bihar? Corruption has reached every place that it can. I always thought that Maharashtra was a very nicey-nicey state. However, you can find corruption in Maharashtra also. There are problems that persist in equal quantities in both the states. But, it is how the people deal with the situation that differs in both the places. In Maharashtra, if you pay the bribe, you actually can expect to get your work done. Not that I endorse such a practice, but in Bihar, there's no guarantee that such a thing can take place.

In Bihar, a threshold has been crossed wherein no one follows any rules nowadays because no one 'else' follows any rules nowadays. I remember how a very rich guy with a starched kurta and a golden chain dangling in his neck, spat publicly on Patna Railway station, caring zilch about the people surrounding him. Such a thing would have evoked atleast a protest from people in Nasik or Mumbai. But there is again a difference. If someone is in some kind of a problem, people in Maharashtra will not take notice, but in Bihar, people will indeed ask.

I often ask this question to myself: I am a proud Bihari, but what Bihari do I represent? The Bihari who stays back in Bihar, works the shit out of himself but still problems of caste, economy and corruption prevent him from progressing, or those who directly or indirectly have come out of that hole and with their persistence and hard work, have made a name for themselves. The answer is obvious.

What is bad is the current situation in Bihar. In a way, us Biharis, the great migrant populace can be blamed for it. They say that the talent is out of Bihar. And that's why Bihar is in a bad state. No. Biharis aren't genetically much different from other communities. The emerging socio-economic conditions of the post independence era made life difficult for people and they went out and progressed. I guess something similar would have happened had Andhra would have got a Lalu Yadav as a CM. Conditions became averse and the same people fought hard against the system and won and became known. However, its the failures that the junta always remembers and not the successes.

Coming to the conclusion: I have just one request to you all. Whenever you deal with me, deal with me as Siddharth Seth, not as a Bihari, or an Indian, or an RPian, or a KGPian, or a THOKa.. the list is endless. Treat me for what I am. I am made up of 'all' of these things and not just one of them. I am a proud Bihari, a proud Indian and a proud lots of things. I wouldn't want to go and prove to every Tom Dick and Harry about my group identification. Tell me when I am wrong, why I am wrong. Don't discard my mistakes as being mistakes because I belong to a particular community. Criticize me individually for my mistakes. Never blame an entire community for the mistakes or wrong doings of a few. Remember a cult or a group for all the good things that it did as a group.

Check your watches, you are in the 21st Century...

Comments invited. They will go a long way in teaching me.

15 Comments:

At 9:58 pm, Blogger Unknown said...

Hey Sid, great post. 100 times better than mine, the mark of a perfectionist. You are much more refined and suave, and yes, u rightly said I am an individual, a representative of various groups, do not judge the groups by my misdeeds.

 
At 10:51 pm, Blogger Philotics said...

Surely, u 2 'bihari's (Modi and u)are giving it a shape of war-cry. Come on, u urself have pointed out that, it is a general behavior of Indians to make fun of each other. So what's the big deal? Everybody are proud to be a member of his locality...and everybody SHOULD be too. So what's the point in making such poignant blogs, that too in succession?

 
At 11:10 pm, Blogger naween said...

if the humor was confined to occasional jokes, i think i would have been fine...but the word bihari has today become synonymous with corruption and dishonest behaviour...ppl don't realize that biharis are perhaps the most friendly guys in this country...will do anything for a proper bhaat :D...and yet all that gets projected is the scams and crime...i think if educated biharis like us don't cringe at the sound of the word bihari and try to correct this notion in our own small ways, it would go a long way in improving the public image of bihar

ps: cud u plz tell me how to write the blog in hindi, i was trying it today, changed the language settings but cudn't see the hindi in the compose mode:(...

 
At 11:31 pm, Blogger Scube said...

to Kapil: thanks for your post which inspired me to write this one..

to Arnab: thanks for the comment.. agreed that successive blogs are pretty suggestive of the fact that we are looking at it as a war.. the world is pretty small and life pretty short to engage in a mindless thing like war on any other community.. i agree with you that the blog is quite poignant, but believe me, it needed to be done.. i haven't painted a very rosy picture of Bihar at all and also, by not doing so, i don't want to earn brownie points for being a neutral guy.. the facts about the state are there for everyone to see, and I, an IIT Kharagpur student sitting comfortably on my chair with all forms of technology around me, cannot even claim to champion the cause of countless underprivileged of Bihar, but atleast urge people to become more receptive and aware.. I sometimes commit the mistake of marking every bengali as lethargic, but you are one example of an industrious bengali.. and you are bengali for me because you speak bangla, you talk of bangla literature and so on..
thanks again for the comment.. as i said, it makes me learn :)

to Naveen: thanks dear for the refreshing comment.. yeah bhojpuri with its sweet endings is indeed a very sweet language :).. i shall never cringe at the mention of the word Bihar and nor would I blindly neglect all the things that are going wrong with Bihar at this time..
as for writing the blogs in Hindi, I have posted a link on your blog..

Cheers !
Siddharth

 
At 6:19 am, Blogger Abhir said...

:)I guess.... every state, anywhere in the world, would be proud to have at leeeeeast one Siddharth Seth !!!

(heyyyy......did u know the letters of my name correspond one-on-one with that of Bihar & that Lalooji has helped to increase the revenue from railways in his term as Railway minister....and that he received a pat from our beloved Manmohan Singh for his innovative reforms....ooops ....i talked a bit extra..)

Take care...!
We all are proud of u !

 
At 2:40 pm, Blogger RTR said...

Wow!!Seth.You write so fluent and so vivid.Yah!One should be judged by his/her own individual capabilities and achievements rather than by linking him/her to the community he/she belongs.
Every community or state or cult has got its good and bad points and what public knows of it is which aspects are frequently publicised by media and all.

 
At 10:12 pm, Blogger kpowerinfinity said...

seth itna funda mat maar ... jaldi upar sidhar jaayega

PS: I havent read teh post yet :P .. but still i can imagine tum kitna funda maara hoga!

 
At 4:09 am, Blogger insane freak said...

brilliant post... says it all rite?

 
At 5:59 pm, Blogger catalyst said...

brilliantly executed arguments :)
you are the first one who is not trying to feign ignorance about what all is wrong with bihar. Not that it matters, but I respect you for accepting things as they are. Acceptance is always the first step towards solving a problem, and this was probably the reason I never had respect for biharis in general, they try to mask reality, they hate being told that bihar sucks. But when there is no pretense you have no reason to scoff at.

 
At 6:00 pm, Blogger catalyst said...

brilliantly executed arguments :)
you are the first one who is not trying to feign ignorance about what all is wrong with bihar. Not that it matters, but I respect you for accepting things as they are. Acceptance is always the first step towards solving a problem, and this was probably the reason I never had respect for biharis in general, they try to mask reality, they hate being told that bihar sucks. But when there is no pretense you have no reason to scoff at.

 
At 8:43 am, Blogger Vineet Pandey said...

Excellent post..
Yes, the first thing that hit me when I came to college was being labelled as a bihari, and then being laughed at, and seriously I couldn't find what was so funny.
Thankfully I have some great friends and also I have debated my way to keeping people's mouths shut about speaking ill of a person from Bihar. But I still don't know if I have been able to remove the thoughts from their mind. Its difficult. I can't play mom and dad to 19 year olds, but I tried my best, and I'm still doing so.
Last day itself I fought a college mate on Orkut who asked a junior to go and stink in NIT Jamshedpur as it is in Bihar.(Technically wrong though ;) )

 
At 8:44 am, Blogger Vineet Pandey said...

And Oh yes! I shall be putting up a fiesta of posts on Bihar on my blog shortly.
This one will surely be there.
:)

 
At 2:51 pm, Blogger Unknown said...

Completely rubbish blog. Born and brought up in Maharashtra and crying about Bihar. Confused about identity?

 
At 9:51 pm, Blogger Unknown said...

hey bhaite.... bihar cnt b compared with maharashtra as mahrashtra is way ahead... so better live here respecting the sentiments of here... there is no way where bihar can stand... u bhaites cum here strt making lobbies... one day surely bhaites lyk u wud make a biharashtra....

 
At 6:39 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bihar is d best!!

 

Post a Comment

<< Home